Deere vs AGCO vs CNH vs Lindsay vs Alamo: Which Farm Equipment Stock Is Worth Buying at the Bottom of the Cycle?

2026-11-19

Deere is the world’s largest farm equipment maker, with a large construction arm and a captive finance company. AGCO (Fendt, Massey Ferguson, Valtra) is a Europe-heavy number three. CNH (Case IH, New Holland) is number two and is selling 70% of its construction business to Kobelco to become a pure agriculture company. Lindsay makes center-pivot irrigation and road-safety equipment. Alamo makes mowers, street sweepers, snow and roadside-maintenance vehicles, mostly for governments. All are at or near the bottom of a severe farm cycle, except Alamo, whose demand is driven more by municipal budgets.

MeasureDEAGCOCNHLNNALG
Intrinsic value, DCF (range)$481 ($351 to $661)$139 ($95 to $197)$16.70 ($11.30 to $23.70)$94 ($67 to $130)$166 ($122 to $224)
Intrinsic value, MEV (range)$468 ($352 to $600)$108 ($70 to $154)$13.20 ($8.50 to $18.90)$88 ($63 to $117)$150 ($111 to $196)
Blended fair value (range)$475 ($400 to $550)$120 ($95 to $145)$14.60 ($11.50 to $18)$91 ($75 to $110)$158 ($130 to $190)
PE, current-year earnings34.7x (FY26E $18.11)18.7x (2026E adj. $5.50)23.9x (2026E adj. $0.46)18.6x (FY26 $5.33)14.1x (2026E adj. about $9.25, unverified)
PE, normalized24.2x11.4x10.0x18.0x13.0x
PEG (normalized PE / growth)3.52.32.03.62.2

PE note: current-year multiples look high everywhere because earnings are at a trough. Normalized PE is the better guide. No PEG is below 1, so none is cheap on growth alone.

At-a-Glance Scorecard

ItemDEAGCOCNHLNNALG
Simple, sustainable model?YesYesYes, restructuringYesYes
MoatYes, wide: brand, dealers, tech, financeNarrow: brands, dealersNarrow: brands, dealersNarrow: niche leaderNarrow: niche brands, dealers
Management aligned?YesMostlyMixedYesMostly
Price vs valueOvervalued 33%Undervalued 14%Undervalued 25%Overvalued 9%Undervalued 18%
Margin of safetyMinus 33%14%25%Minus 9%18%
Free cash flow strong?YesYes over cycleWeak recentlyYesYes
Balance sheet strong?Yes (equipment ops)AdequateAdequateYesAdequate
Biggest riskPaying a peak multiple at a troughLong European downturnExecution and finance-arm lossesLumpy international projectsAcquisition missteps
Buy price, 9% over 16 years$398$72$10.07$63$107
Buy if market closed 5 years?Yes, below $400Yes, below $85Yes, below $10Yes, below $65Yes, below $110
Snapshot verdictDo not buyHold / watchHold / watchDo not buyHold / watch

Inputs used to calculate intrinsic value:

InputDEAGCOCNHLNNALG
Normalized EPS (range)$26 ($22 to $30)$9.00 ($7 to $11)$1.10 ($0.85 to $1.35)$5.50 ($4.50 to $6.50)$10.00 ($8.50 to $11.50)
Owner earnings per share$24.00$8.75$1.05$5.50$9.00
Growth, years 1 to 5 / 6 to 107% / 5%5% / 4%5% / 4%5% / 4%6% / 5%
Discount rate9.5%10%10%9.5%9.5%
Terminal growth3%2.5%2.5%2.5%2.5%
MEV multiple (range)18x (16x to 20x)12x (10x to 14x)12x (10x to 14x)16x (14x to 18x)15x (13x to 17x)
Diluted shares270.8M69.5Mabout 1.25B (unverified)about 10.2Mabout 12.1M

Historical Earnings

Diluted EPS ($)DE (FY Oct)AGCOCNH (adjusted)LNN (FY Aug)ALG
20164.81 (unverified)1.96n/a1.853.50
20176.662.32n/a2.173.84
20187.213.58n/a1.886.30
201910.141.630.840.205.38
20208.705.650.283.564.91
202118.9911.851.353.886.78
202223.2811.87about 1.535.948.58
202334.6315.63about 1.756.5411.42
202425.62(5.69)about 1.056.019.69
202518.509.75about 0.556.788.64
2026about 18.11 (consensus)5.50 (adj. guide)0.46 (guide midpoint)5.335.14 (9M GAAP)

CNH figures before 2022 include the Iveco truck business, since spun off, and are not comparable.

Deep Dive

Business Understanding

DEAGCOCNHLNNALG
Main productsLarge and small ag, construction, financeTractors, combines, precision agTractors, combines, precision agIrrigation pivots, road barriersMowers, sweepers, snow and roadside equipment
Demand driverFarm income, constructionFarm income, EuropeFarm income, Brazil, North AmericaFarm income, water scarcity, projectsMunicipal and highway budgets
CyclicalityHighHighHighMediumLow to medium

All five sell durable machines through dealers and earn steadier money on parts. The three tractor makers live and die by farm incomes; Deere called 2026 the bottom of the large ag cycle, and AGCO described the weakest industry demand in more than a decade. Lindsay depends partly on large international projects; a roughly $70 million Middle East and North Africa contract is ending. Alamo’s customers are governments, which makes it the least cyclical. None faces a plausible threat of extinction.

Competitive Advantage and Positioning

Deere has the widest moat: the leading brand in North America, the densest dealer network, a technology lead in automation and precision ag, and a finance arm that helps sell machines. CNH and AGCO are strong number twos and threes, with AGCO’s Fendt dominant in premium European tractors. Lindsay competes mainly with Valmont in irrigation, a two-firm market. Alamo has built leading niche positions through acquisitions. Moats look stable everywhere; CNH’s is the least certain while it restructures.

Financial Strength: Profitability

MeasureDEAGCOCNHLNNALG
10-year EPS trendStrong growth, peak 2023Up, volatileDown since 2023Steady growthSteady growth
Recent marginMid-teens equipment op. margin at trough (unverified)7% adj. operating5.5% adj. industrial EBIT9.8% Q4 operating13% adj. EBITDA
ROIC trend (unverified)High, falling to troughFalling to troughFallingStable, mid-teensStable, around 10%

Deere’s peak EPS of $34.63 in 2023 shows its earning power; even at a trough it expects $4.75 to $5.0 billion of net income. Lindsay has grown EPS from $1.85 to over $5 in a decade with no debt strain. Alamo has compounded through acquisitions. CNH’s adjusted EPS has fallen by roughly two thirds since 2023.

Financial Strength: Balance Sheet

Deere’s consolidated debt is dominated by John Deere Financial, which funds customer loans; its equipment operations are conservatively financed (detail unverified). AGCO carries net debt of about $2.26 billion. CNH’s industrial balance sheet is adequate, but its finance arm lost $77 million in Q3 2026 and it booked a $156 million tax valuation charge. Lindsay has historically held net cash (current figure unverified). Alamo had $230.7 million of cash at September 30, then spent $158.7 million on Econ in October; net leverage is likely modest.

Financial Strength: Cash Flow

DEAGCOCNHLNNALG
Recent cash flowFY26 operating cash flow guidance raisedRecord 2025 FCF $740M; seasonal 2026 outflow2026 industrial FCF guide $300M to $450MFunded $80.7M buybacks in FY269M operating cash flow $83.2M, capex $16.1M
Share countDown 48% since 1996Down 20% since 2015Falling (unverified)Down about 6% in FY26Rising slightly

Deere, AGCO and Lindsay are steady repurchasers. Alamo uses cash for acquisitions instead, so its share count drifts up slowly.

Margin of Safety

Only CNH (25%), Alamo (18%) and AGCO (14%) trade below fair value. If valuations were 20% too high, CNH’s fair value would be about $11.70, Alamo’s about $126 and AGCO’s about $96: Alamo and AGCO would be fairly priced, CNH barely cheap. Deere and Lindsay offer no margin of safety at all.

Mispricing Thesis

Deere is priced as if the recovery is already here: 24x normalized earnings for a cyclical. Lindsay’s price ignores the fiscal 2027 revenue gap left by the ending MENA project. AGCO and CNH are discounted because investors doubt a timely European and Brazilian recovery; CNH also carries restructuring noise. Alamo fell after a Q3 miss and $33.3 million of charges to exit Dixie Chopper and Boxer, which looks temporary if the portfolio clean-up works.

Management and Capital Allocation

DEAGCOCNHLNNALG
RecordExcellent; disciplined buybacksGood cost control; costly 2024 write-downsFrequent restructuring; Kobelco deal sharpens focusConservative, buyback-friendlySerial acquirer, now pruning
ConcernCEO also ChairmanCEO also ChairmanExecution, governance changesLow growth investmentIntegration risk

Executive pay and insider ownership could not be verified this session for any of the five.

Long-Term Outlook

Food demand, larger farms, labor shortages and automation favor all three tractor makers, with Deere best placed to profit from technology. Lindsay benefits from water scarcity and irrigation efficiency. Alamo benefits from steady infrastructure and roadside spending. In a recession, Alamo and Lindsay should hold up best; the tractor makers would see sharp volume declines, as in 2024 to 2026.

Risk Assessment and Red Flag Scan

FlagDEAGCOCNHLNNALG
Declining free cash flowNoNoYesNoMild
Debt rising without earningsNoPartialPartialNoWatch after Econ
Misaligned payNot verifiedNot verifiedNot verifiedNot verifiedNot verified
Serial acquisitionsNoNoNoNoYes
Accounting complexityFinance armMany adjustmentsFinance arm, tax chargesLowPortfolio charges
Moat erosionNoNoPossibleNoNo
ConcentrationAg cycleEuropeBrazil, EuropeProject lumpsGovernment budgets
OtherTariff cost about $1.1B in FY26Finance arm lossesMENA gapQ3 miss

Disconfirming Evidence

  • Deere: at 35x current earnings and 24x normalized, any delay in recovery or a shift in technology competition could cut the price by a third. The bear case wins at $629.
  • AGCO: Europe, its profit engine, fell 18% in Q3; a third bad year would push fair value toward $83. The bear and bull cases are balanced at $103.
  • CNH: earnings have fallen two thirds, the finance arm is losing money, and transformation stories often disappoint. The bull case (normalized EPS of $1.10) requires faith in execution. Roughly balanced, with low confidence.
  • Lindsay: fiscal 2027 faces a revenue hole of about $65 million and shrinking irrigation margins; Q4 strength rested on cost cuts and buybacks. The bear case wins at $99.
  • Alamo: serial acquirers eventually overpay, and the Q3 charges show past mistakes. But the core businesses are steady and adjusted margins held at 13%. The bull case is modestly stronger.

Scenario Valuations

ScenarioDEAGCOCNHLNNALG
Bear value$351$83$9.90$65$116
Base value$475$120$14.60$91$158
Bull value$630$176$21.30$124$210
Bear assumptionsEPS $22, 16x, 10.5%EPS $7, 10x, 11%EPS $0.85, 10x, 11%EPS $4.50, 14x, 10.5%EPS $8.50, 13x, 10.5%
Bull assumptionsEPS $30, 20x, 8.5%EPS $11, 14x, 9%EPS $1.35, 14x, 9%EPS $6.50, 18x, 8.5%EPS $11.50, 17x, 8.5%
Entry conditionBelow $400, mid-downturnBelow $85, troughBelow $10, troughBelow $65Below $110
Exit conditionAbove $550Above $145Above $18Above $110Above $190

Margins assumed in the base case: Deere equipment operating margin about 18%, AGCO about 10%, CNH industrial EBIT about 10%, Lindsay operating about 14%, Alamo adjusted EBITDA about 13% (all unverified long-run estimates).

Valuation Discipline

  • Discount rates: 9.5% for Deere, Lindsay and Alamo (stronger balance sheets, steadier earnings); 10% for AGCO and CNH (deeper cycles, more leverage or restructuring).
  • Terminal growth: 2.5% for all except Deere (3%, given its technology lead), below long-run nominal GDP of about 4%.
  • Owner earnings growth: as in the inputs table, reflecting GDP-like volume plus parts, technology and buybacks; Alamo’s includes acquisitions.
  • Normalized EPS: the midpoint between recent trough and peak earnings at today’s share count, cross-checked against the ten-year average. For CNH, post-Iveco years only.

DCF sensitivity (base case, $ per share):

ChangeDEAGCOCNHLNNALG
Growth minus 2 points41412014.4081143
Growth plus 2 points55916119.30109192
Discount rate plus 2 points36310913.1072127
Discount rate minus 2 points70519223.00133235

Reconciliation: DCF and MEV differ by 29% for AGCO and 26% for CNH, so MEV is weighted 60% for both because cyclical multiples capture troughs better than smooth DCFs. For the other three, the methods are within 10% and weighted equally.

Buy Price and Margin of Safety

Method: normalized EPS grows as in the inputs table, exits at the MEV multiple and is discounted at the target rate, with the present value of dividends added. Projected 16-year exit values: DE $1,234, AGCO $223, CNH $27.20, LNN $181, ALG $360. Estimates sit within roughly plus or minus 25%.

Maximum buy price over 16 years (with dividends):

Target returnDEAGCOCNHLNNALG
5%$685$123$16.81$107$187
6%$596$107$14.73$93$162
7%$519$94$12.94$82$141
8%$454$82$11.40$72$123
9%$398$72$10.07$63$107
10%$350$63$8.92$56$94

Maximum buy price at 9% a year (with dividends):

HorizonDEAGCOCNHLNNALG
5 years$457$96$12.18$80$136
7 years$453$91$11.82$77$132
10 years$448$85$11.33$73$125
12 years$430$80$10.87$69$118
14 years$413$76$10.45$66$112
16 years$398$72$10.07$63$107

Implied 16-year annual return at today’s price: DE 5.6%, AGCO 6.3%, CNH 8.3%, LNN 5.5%, ALG 7.6%. None meets 9% over 16 years. CNH and Alamo meet it over 5 to 7 years.

Sell Discipline

DEAGCOCNHLNNALG
Thesis triggersLoss of tech lead; finance-arm credit lossesAdj. margin under 6% for two years; big debt-funded dealFailed transformation; finance losses persistLoss of irrigation share; buybacks funded by debtLarge overpriced acquisition; adj. EBITDA margin under 11%
Trim above$550$145$18$110$190
Exit above$660$200$23$130$235

Price triggers mark where the stock would require bull-case assumptions.

Risk and Opportunity Profile

Scores 1 to 10; 10 is most favorable.

Risk sub-factor (weight)DEAGCOCNHLNNALG
Financial stability (0.30)86597
Earnings volatility (0.20)43357
Business model risk (0.20)86466
Macro sensitivity (0.15)43356
Market risk (0.15)55554
Risk Score6.24.84.16.46.2

Lindsay, Deere and Alamo carry the lowest risk, driven by balance sheets and, for Alamo, steady government demand. CNH carries the most, driven by earnings volatility and restructuring.

Opportunity sub-factor (weight)DEAGCOCNHLNNALG
Growth potential (0.30)65546
Unit economics (0.20)96576
Competitive advantage (0.20)96566
Valuation asymmetry (0.20)25736
Catalysts (0.10)56645
Opportunity Score6.35.55.54.85.9

Deere scores highest on quality but lowest on valuation asymmetry. Alamo offers the best balance of quality and price.

Classification

DEAGCOCNHLNNALG
StageGrowing over cyclesStableStable to decliningStableGrowing
Peter LynchCyclical with stalwart traitsCyclicalCyclical turnaroundSlow grower, mildly cyclicalStalwart built by acquisition
Charlie MungerGreat business, price too highGood business, fair priceFair business, too hardGood niche business, full priceGood business, fair price

Data Used Versus Ignored

Used: ten-year EPS, latest quarterly releases, management guidance, share count trends and balance sheet items stated in releases.

Set aside: trailing GAAP PEs distorted by charges; 2023 peak earnings as a base; CNH results that include Iveco; analyst price targets.

Unverified: early EPS for DE and ALG, CNH 2022 to 2024 EPS and share count, ROIC histories, Deere equipment-operations debt, Lindsay’s and Alamo’s net cash or debt, all ownership and pay data. These are why CNH is rated low confidence and the others medium.

Summary and Verdict

RankCompanyVerdictFair value rangeBuy below (9%, 16 years)Meets 9% at today’s price?
1Alamo GroupHold / watch; nearest to a buy$130 to $190$107No (7.6%)
2CNH IndustrialHold / watch; speculative$11.50 to $18$10No (8.3%)
3AGCOHold / watch$95 to $145$72No (6.3%)
4LindsayDo not buy$75 to $110$63No (5.5%)
5DeereDo not buy$400 to $550$398No (5.6%)

Deere is the best business but the worst-priced stock. Alamo offers the best mix of quality, stability and discount, and would meet the 9% goal at about $107. CNH is the cheapest on paper and nearly meets the goal at $11, but its earnings and restructuring make it the least certain. AGCO is a fair-priced cyclical. Lindsay is a fine company priced above value ahead of a known revenue gap.

Disclaimer: This analysis is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice. Always perform your own due diligence or consult with a financial advisor before making investment decisions.

Scroll to Top